Mr and Mrs Y were sought by Hungary to face trial for fraud offences. The couple co-parented their two young children, one of whom was autistic and non-verbal.
It was argued that the surrender of the couple would have a detrimental impact upon both children such as to violate their rights under Article 8 ECHR. Owing to the complexities of the case, evidence and submissions took place at two hearings in February and August 2024. The Court heard live evidence from a range of experts, including a psychologist, Dr Jessica Crumpton, who concluded that both children would “suffer devastating harm” in the event of their parents’ extradition. Discharging both parents, District Judge Pilling placed great weight on the fact that “Dr Crumpton made it clear how much extra work and responsibility comes with parenting a child with additional needs."
Ben Joyes appeared for Mr Y throughout proceedings. Mrs Y was represented by Lucy Waterstone and, later, Douglas Wotherspoon. All counsel were instructed by Rebecca Field of Hodge, Jones and Allen.
The CPS will not appeal the judgment.
